Name the player:

[Tucker]

fair enough but during SL war and in Origin mid 90's he had to play at hooker to accommodate kkimmorleyand toovey. Johns was a very good 7 and capable 9
As for his brother, matty was a pretty average player

Yes. He was moved out of the 7 by those guys. So saying he is not only the best 7 ever, but arguably the best player ever is over the top for mine which makes him a prime candidate to answer the question that started this thread.
Matty isn’t held in the same high esteem so that cancels him out for this little game we’re playing.
Matty’s popularity has been post footy as a talking head with great insight. I don’t think he is overrated in that field.

 

[The Chad]

Might not be a popular belief but I was always a little surprised about hearing how Brad Clyde was the greatest forward in the game at the time.

After that, Brett Mullins was never the player they made him out to be.

Currently- Gutherson.

 

[matchball]

Definitely Robbie Farah.

 

[Fade.To.Black]

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Hindmarsh. Was just a tackle dummy most of his career.

 

[innsaneink]

Brett Finch
Mark Hughes
Sam Harris
Bryan Fletcher
Mark Riddell

 

[Flippedy]

Nicho Hynes