Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

The Chad said:
Yes- I'd take Garner back.

He offers a good athlete on the edge & is an emergency centre. We actually lack that kind of player, unless Kepaoa could actually take up that role.
Click to expand...
Garner would be much better value than iPap & has experience with Luai as well.

Garner or Lemeulu for me unless we can land a Haumole.
 
jrtiger said:
scored four tries against Castleford a month ago, the first one is particularly impressive. take a look.

Click to expand...
Just watched it he’s got some pace, but was out of position a couple of times defensively from what I saw. One did result in Nene MacDonald scoring. Bit concerned with signing SL backs very rarely do they do well in NRL.
 
Where ever ice p ends up good luck to them the bloke has been a bum since he got here good riddance I say
 
Vicious said:
Anyone who hasn’t seen it, do yourself a favour and watch the NSW Cup highlights from last weekend, Billy Burns with the Jets and Matt Doorey with the Eels.
I know plenty will say it’s only NSW Cup, but rest assured these two have been dominating NSW Cup like this for a long long time, now in the prime of their careers and crying out for a regular NRL opportunity.
Couple them with the emerging Sam Fainu and a few other prospects currently in our own lower grades and we can possibly have strike on our NRL edges moving forward, something we have not had for a long, long time.
With Papali’i likely departing, I would hope we are also looking at an experienced no nonsense player with much better leg speed than any of our current forwards in Jack Williams to either start at 13 or bring impact like he does at the Sharks.
Click to expand...
Yeah, a couple more reserve graders will do the trick.
 
Vicious said:
That’s where the good players come from funnily enough.
I just give you Scott Sorensen as an example, do you want another 100 names as further examples ?
Click to expand...
Any of those examples of players coming into a side looking down the barrel of 3 spoons in a row and absolutely killing it?
 
GNR4LIFE said:
We couldn’t get anything out of Papali’, yet Matt Doory is going to come and be an X-factor? Give me a break
Click to expand...
At less than a third of the price Doorey is absolutely a better attacking edge forward than Papali’i.
We can’t score a try so players who run hard, can bust tackles and make line breaks are required.
The added bonus of signing a few players on fringe player contracts is it allows us to upgrade others we need to keep and possibly pay more if a quality player becomes available.
 
Vicious said:
At less than a third of the price Doorey is absolutely a better attacking edge forward than Papali’i.
We can’t score a try so players who run hard, can bust tackles and make line breaks are required.
The added bonus of signing a few players on fringe player contracts is it allows us to upgrade others we need to keep and possibly pay more if a quality player becomes available.
Click to expand...
And some of you wonder why we never get anywhere.
 
Vicious said:
Anyone who hasn’t seen it, do yourself a favour and watch the NSW Cup highlights from last weekend, Billy Burns with the Jets and Matt Doorey with the Eels.
I know plenty will say it’s only NSW Cup, but rest assured these two have been dominating NSW Cup like this for a long long time, now in the prime of their careers and crying out for a regular NRL opportunity.
Couple them with the emerging Sam Fainu and a few other prospects currently in our own lower grades and we can possibly have strike on our NRL edges moving forward, something we have not had for a long, long time.
With Papali’i likely departing, I would hope we are also looking at an experienced no nonsense player with much better leg speed than any of our current forwards in Jack Williams to either start at 13 or bring impact like he does at the Sharks.
Click to expand...
Doorey yes. Burns no. Billy Burns is talented but not consistent. Not sure we are a team that can get the best out of him
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
GNR4LIFE said:
Is he really going to perform better at our club than Papali’i?
Click to expand...
Funny you should say that.

I may be a poor judge but I've seen Garner run better lines when he was with us than Papali'i has in his time here, sure we have never used him well but he never convinced me that he actually wanted to be here.

That aside I thought we had only just found his most effective position at lock and now he is gone.

I hope this time we have a plan and have someone lined up that wants to be here and actually improves us.
 
InGalvinWeTrust said:
Hear me out...

Brad Arthur to the tigers.
Click to expand...
Gut feeling or
Matt Preston's tomato sauce
 
InGalvinWeTrust said:
He hasn't had a chance to play in position is what I don't understand. Let him play at lock or 5/8 before saying he is write off. He isn't a hooker, and has only played hooker when forced to internationally
Click to expand...
I agree, if there was anything to be concerned about id say it’s the hamstring injuries at such a young age. Does anybody know how many he has had? Hope it doesn’t turn out like Turbo’s..
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 465 (members: 46, guests: 419)
Forever online: Tigergran, Geo
Back
Top