Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

AmericanHistoryX said:
Baddabing Baddaboom. Its the older ones letting us down.
Click to expand...
Not really.
Ask yourself which positions in every NRL team have the most influence in their team scoring points ?
1 & 7 is your answer and all bar the two games we won, our 1 & 7 have had the direction and influence of headless chooks.
Galvin as our 6 has had some good moments, but needs help from those around him.
Very limited tackle busts or attacking threat from our edge back row, next to no impact from whoever has played right centre, not near enough from our wingers, but as previously discussed that was much better last night.
No impact from our 13 except when Papali’i played there against the Knights.
Twal played strong against the Dolphins, but doesn’t have the passing ability to be a long term 13.
Apj has mostly been good, but clearly playing more minutes than his body can handle.
Bad bench rotations from the coach, I can’t put that down to inexperience, just stupidity.
The one constant is our middles have made good metres for the majority of the season, of course we need a few more offloads from them and at times better line speed when defending.
 
I think some of us need to cool our jets a bit getting worried about this year and next year. We were never going to win more than 7 games this year like some thought. Billy Slater reckons we are in for a big improvement over the next few years. JT (Cowboys legend) said that out of Bulldogs, Dragons, Tigers if he was a young player he'd sign with Tigers based on the future. This is despite Bulldogs having great defence and improving heaps this year as well as Dragons improving heaps too. Our young guns will come good. 2 legends of the game who think we are headed in the right direction. We've hit rock bottom a few times, but this is just part of the evolution of the team. Who knows, maybe Benji will be gone by round 5 next year, and we have a new coach and we start playing great, anything can happen. It's not a permanent position
 
rugbygoated said:
I think some of us need to cool our jets a bit getting worried about this year and next year. We were never going to win more than 7 games this year like some thought. Billy Slater reckons we are in for a big improvement over the next few years. JT (Cowboys legend) said that out of Bulldogs, Dragons, Tigers if he was a young player he'd sign with Tigers based on the future. This is despite Bulldogs having great defence and improving heaps this year as well as Dragons improving heaps too. Our young guns will come good. 2 legends of the game who think we are headed in the right direction. We've hit rock bottom a few times, but this is just part of the evolution of the team. Who knows, maybe Benji will be gone by round 5 next year, and we have a new coach and we start playing great, anything can happen. It's not a permanent position
Click to expand...
Gus has been saying all year that our young players will all be coming good next year, he said this time next year you just wait and see
 
We have to unearth players that provide points. 2 tries a game is not good enough.

Luai will help but we need a change in our attacking structures. It’s not just the cattle, when Penrith wingers get the ball, it’s so far in field in comparison to when ours do if it even makes it out that far.

I don’t see Turuva making a huge difference. Need some X factor in the backs. Makasini/Large sound like the best candidates but they are years away and that’s if they stay.
 
weststigerman said:
We have to unearth players that provide points. 2 tries a game is not good enough.

Luai will help but we need a change in our attacking structures. It’s not just the cattle, when Penrith wingers get the ball, it’s so far in field in comparison to when ours do if it even makes it out that far.

I don’t see Turuva making a huge difference. Need some X factor in the backs. Makasini/Large sound like the best candidates but they are years away and that’s if they stay.
Click to expand...
Manly lose a few backs to injury and go out, sign Aaron Schoupp....

We never really try and address our issues.
Rolling out career failures like Naden and Kepoa every week is so painful.

I hope they're telling Naden he needs to find a new deal elsewhere.
 
Vicious said:
A little birdy told me that both Sam Stonestreet and Kade Dykes are getting frustrated at lack of NRL opportunities at the Sharks and would be open to a move for better NRL opportunities even though both are currently contracted until the end of the 2025 season.
Dykes has been injury prone which is not ideal, but it’s a well known fact he is one of the most talented emerging playing within the NRL system that is not currently playing regular NRL.
Equally at home at fullback, 5/8 or centre, a player with his talent would improve our attack immensely particularly if playing fullback.
Stonestreet is the prototype big, tall and fast winger who always competes hard for the high ball and regularly makes good post contact metres. He can also play centre and would be a great acquisition for a team like us.
Jeral Skelton and Grant Anderson are both off contract, they are both big, tall, fast powerful athletes who would help improve our depth and push hard for a regular NRL position.
Blake Wilson is another who is under contract with the Bulldogs, but has clearly shown he’s a more than capable NRL standard winger, very good under the high ball and a good finisher. He can’t get a look in at the Bulldogs NRL team when they are full strength, why wouldn’t he be looking elsewhere for a better opportunity?
Toby Sexton is a much more natural halfback than anyone we have, has a much better kicking game than anyone we have also. He’s off contract and I think he’d be well and truly open to a mid season switch frustrated at lack of NRL opportunities at the Bulldogs.
Matt Doorey and Billy Burns both good hole running edge back rowers that would add much needed depth and potentially become NRL regulars with us this season if they made a mid season switch.
Cooper Jenkins a big, tall and mobile prop currently dominating Qld Cuo and currently has a 2nd tier contract with the Dolphins. A definite NRL player of the future, he would definitely improve our depth and offer a prop with good leg speed and try scoring ability, something we don’t have.
Click to expand...
Do you know what the common dominator is in each of the above?
They have spent more than a year in reserves honing their craft.
What’s to say our own aren’t on a similar wanted list after 18months of reserve grade.
 
liltiger said:
No point getting new players while we have the same attacking coach. Pretty sure Farah is our attacking coach this year and last year. Time to move on and bring someone with more experience in. Our attack is pedantic and uninventive.
Click to expand...

liltiger said:
No point getting new players while we have the same attacking coach. Pretty sure Farah is our attacking coach this year and last year. Time to move on and bring someone with more experience in. Our attack is pedantic and uninventive.
Click to expand...
Was Marshall last year
 
Vicious said:
Alaimalo is improving all of the time.
I watched his first few games in NSW Cup and he was scared to catch a high ball and could not make a tackle to save his life.
He is now attack every high ball with confidence, making try saving tackles and his hit ups out of our danger zone are strong.
Charlie has unfortunately missed one on one tackles that are leading to tries too often this season, but if he can somehow fix that he has generally been very safe under the high ball and is our only player aside from Olam who regularly hits top speed with his hit ups.
Surely nobody can be blaming our wingers for our recent losses, but we do need more tackle busting line breaking ability from at least one of our wingers.
Click to expand...
To me Alaimalo looks kinda like Maumolo towards the end of his career. Big, good on the air but slow, little go forward as he's just tall and easily gets dominated. If he can't regularly be making 10m+ and breaking tackles then he's of limited value. He's improving for sure, but comparing him to our other backs is a very low bar. As a fill in for a year he's a gap filler but unless he can find some speed from somewhere, at 30 next season he's just not a project that will deliver us much value.
I'd take Stonestreet or Skelton over him in a heartbeat. And so should Benji
 
Needaname said:
Was Marshall last year
Click to expand...
You could be right , Marshall might have been last years attacking coach, though imo I think Marshall was coaching while Sheens was there taking the hits in the media. That's just my conspiracy theory though I could very well be wrong.
 
tigermate said:
yep. the same ones that sent him back to reggies, before they lost, then brought him back, and then went on a winning streak without ponga. lol. the same ones currently in 8th.
Click to expand...
Do you only have free to air TV and just rely on reading the results to assess players?

Hastings stifles the Knights attack - his kicking is substandard and he has a propensity to give away stupid penalties in every match!

They are winning despite him - NOT because of him!
 
liltiger said:
You could be right , Marshall might have been last years attacking coach, though imo I think Marshall was coaching while Sheens was there taking the hits in the media. That's just my conspiracy theory though I could very well be wrong.
Click to expand...
I have no doubt you’re right. Sheens was just there to take the heat of Benji with the media and be a backstop
 
BAGNF05 said:
Hardly ever, they pick him up and roll him on to his back so the next poor bugger gets smashed too.
Click to expand...
For all of Bulas attributes, he doesn't seem to be able to play out the back like the top fullbacks.

Defensively, he's pretty amazing, but he does lack a little in attack.

After watching Turuva play fullback, I'd be tempted to give him a shot there and move Bula to wing or centre.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 454 (members: 46, guests: 408)
Forever online: Tigergran, Geo
Back
Top